Reread, Rewrite, Burn Tag


I saw this tag on Kristen Kraves Books and thought it looked fun, so I gave it a whirl. I randomized my books on Goodreads and this is what I got!


  • Randomly choose 3 books
  • For each group, decide which book to burn, which one to rewrite, and which to reread (like Marry, Boff, Kill).
  • Repeat until you completed three rounds (or six) (or however many you want to do).

REREAD: A Conjuring of Light FOR SURE. Love that book.

REWRITE: I read A Northern Light a veeeery long time ago when I was maybe 14 or 15, and to be honest I don’t really remember what it’s even about, but I do remember that I thought it was just okay and I’d expected more from it. So, rewrite.

BURN: I wasn’t a huge fan of the later Series of Unfortunate Events books, and since this is book 11 in the series, I’m gonna have to say bye, Grim GrottoI’d have to rewrite some plot points in earlier books before I even got to this one to make it work, so I’m burning this out of laziness mostly.

REREAD: Listen, I freaking loved The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo books, but I don’t think I’d ever be able to read them again because that’s some heavy stuff. Magnus Chase is far more pleasant (and I love it), so I must go with Ship of the Dead.

REWRITE: I’ve now realized I’ve walked myself into a corner here, because no way in heck could I ever write or rewrite the complexity that is The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, and I want to burn Cursed Child to the ground, but….THE CURSE CHILD WAS SO WRONG I WANT TO TAKE IT INTO MY OWN HANDS AND MAKE IT RIGHT.

BURN: Forgive me, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo….I love you and I’m sorry you get the short end of the stick, but some books are too good to rewrite, and some must only be read once.

REREAD: I mean…I wouldn’t really care to, but I’ll go with The Fellowship of the Ring. Tolkien’s writing is a bit dense for me, but I read this forever ago so it may not hurt to give it another try. Maybe I’d feel differently?

REWRITE: Some parts of All The Bright Places bored me and were a bit preachy, so maybe I’d tone down the pointedness of it. I also wasn’t a huge fan of how the book set me up for the ending. REWRITE, though I’d feel bad because I could tell how much this book was a reflection of the author’s own experiences in her author’s note.

BURN: Look, I know Animal Farm is an important book and all, but I’m rating these purely on my own enjoyment and while it’d be a quicker reread than Fellowship…..I must choose burn. I wasn’t a huge fan of it in high school when I read it, RIP.

REREAD: OH GOSH okay I’m going to have to go with The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian. I wouldn’t mind rereading Neil Gaiman, but there’s something I wouldn’t mind rewriting about his book. And it would be plain wrong for me to touch Part-Time Indian. AND I very much enjoyed it.

REWRITE: I really enjoyed The Ocean at the End of the Lanebut I would have liked the fantasy to be a bit more solid. It felt a bit too….out there, though I really enjoyed the creepiness of this book. That would all stay.

BURN: I liked The Girl on the Train but I didn’t love it, and it’s my least favorite of these three, so, farewell.


REWRITE: The Gilded Years was a lot drier than I had expected it to be. It’s about a black girl that passes as a white girl in order to go to all white, all-girl college in the late 1800s…but a lot of the chapters were too wordy and frivolous and I did a lot of skimming as a started to realize what would be important and what wouldn’t. I’d tighten it up a bit, maybe add a bit more…plot.

BURN: Impossible was a bit too strange for me and was not a very enjoyable read.  BURN.

REREAD: Order of the Phoenix. I’ll always reread you, Harry ❤ (unless you’re in Cursed Child but that doesn’t count).

REWRITE: I love City of Thieves dearly and wouldn’t not change much, buuut I do remember feeling like some parts dragged a tiny bit, even though it was such a tiny book. This book’s brilliant so I would be better off not touching it, but….with these choices I’ve gotta.

BURN: Bye, Little Women. I thought this book was just okay, anyway.

I think I’ll stop there…that was fun! I’m not going to tag anyone, but if you decide to do this, please tag me so I can see your answers because they’re fun to read 🙂

21 thoughts on “Reread, Rewrite, Burn Tag

    • UGH it’s was THE WORST. I still feel insulted by it. And it was just a really lame plot…like, if I was given the chance to do something with Harry Potter characters at my disposal, I’d try to come up with something a bit more unique and exploratory rather than just….reviving all the dead characters and giving them all cheesy lines.

      Liked by 1 person

      • EXACTLY! It completely relied on rehashing existing plots and characters to try and pull on people’s heartstrings, which I thought was pretty manipulative and a total cop out.

        Some of it was also just downright stupid. *cough* the trolley witch *cough*

        Liked by 1 person

      • I especially hated how characters like Snape and Dumbledore and even Malfoy acknowledge their flawed actions and mistakes from the series and like, apologize??It was like the author read a “list of problematic things in Harry Potter” on Tumblr and decided to fix everything….which only made it more ridiculous.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Ahhhh I hate when people call it book 8!! Though to be fair, even if it had been good I’d still have been opposed to calling it book 8, since it’s not exactly ~Harry’s story,~ but I feel downright insulted when people include it with the original series.

        Liked by 1 person

  1. Omg I love this meme I’ve really gotta do it… I don’t think I know anyone else who’s read A Northern Light but I was super into that book when I was like, 13?? I would probably hate it now hahaha. I also loved the Girl with the Dragon Tattoo books but omg I totally know what you mean about not being able to reread those.


  2. Pingback: Reread, Rewrite, Burn tag – pace, amore, libri

  3. Pingback: AWARD: Brotherhood of the World Award – Diary of a Bookfiend

  4. Pingback: The Playlist Shuffle Tag – Birdie Bookworm

  5. Pingback: Burn, Rewrite, Reread #2 – Sarah Ames-Foley

  6. I love the idea of this tag and I absolutely agree with you on many of the choices you made! For example, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is a really good book, but I probably wouldn’t read it again, because it kind of terrified me and I‘m not emotionally ready to go through that again 😂
    And I‘m currently reading A Gathering of Shadows and loving it, so I‘d probably agree with you on A Conjuring of Light, too 😊

    Liked by 1 person

    • Right?? I loved Girl with the Dragon Tattoo but no way am I ever going through that again….sometimes the best books must be sacrificed 😉 I hope you like A Conjuring of Light! I loved it, though Gathering of Shadows was my favorite of that series!

      Liked by 1 person

  7. Pingback: TAG: The End of the Year Book Tag – Diary of a Bookfiend

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s